440 Pizzeria: Midtown Kingston's Modern Slice of a Neighborhood Favorite |
Across from Kingston High School, a modern pizzeria has earned a following on classic slices, generous deals, and steady hospitality |
On Broadway in the heart of Midtown Kingston, across from Kingston High School, sits 440 Pizzeria. Open at 440 Broadway since 2015, it bills itself as a "new modern pizzeria" serving its neighborhood—yet its appeal is rooted in something old-fashioned: honest New York-style pizza, consistent service, and prices that keep regulars coming back week after week.
A Classic Slice in a Modern Setting
440 Pizzeria specializes in thin-crust, New York-style pizza with a tender crust and a balanced ratio of cheese to sauce. Beyond plain and pepperoni, the kitchen turns out specialty pies—buffalo chicken, BBQ chicken, chicken bacon ranch, taco pizza, and a loaded vegetable pie—alongside wings, garlic knots, fried dough, and salads. The menu widens further with cold and hot subs, paninis, wraps, and full pasta dinners such as chicken parm, baked ziti, and eggplant rollatini, so a pizzeria trip here can easily become a family meal.
Value That Keeps the Neighborhood Coming
Local customers consistently highlight the value, especially the wings and the garlic knots, which reviewers describe as some of the best around. The "Family Deal"—two medium pizzas with a topping, plus wings, garlic sticks, and a two-liter soda—has become a dependable option for Midtown households and for students and staff from the high school directly across the street. As a takeout and delivery favorite, the shop has become a quintessential Kingston spot.
Like many small kitchens, 440 Pizzeria is not perfect on every order, and its review profile reflects that mix of praise and occasional inconsistency. What stands out in the feedback is not just the food but the people: cyclists on the Empire State Trail have written about being welcomed in to warm up and use the restroom on a cold, rainy day, and about the kindness they received alongside their pizza.
What Other Local Pizzerias Can Learn
In a town with plenty of pizza, a neighborhood shop lives or dies on repeat business—and repeat business is built on a reputation for consistent neighborhood pizza and genuine hospitality. When a small restaurant answers feedback, fixes the off nights, and treats every walk-in like a neighbor, its online reviews slowly become its strongest marketing. For independent pizzerias, that steady, customer-driven reputation compounds far more reliably than any single promotion.
Location: 440 Broadway, Kingston, NY 12401 |

Nov 19, 2026
Cycling Around Kingston NY: Bike Routes and Rail Trail Guide 2026
Plan a bike ride around Kingston, NY, with routes for the Rondout waterfront, Wallkill Valley Rail Trail and Ashokan Rail Trail, plus parking and mileage.

Nov 19, 2026
Put Your Business in Kingston’s Weekly Plans
Explore Kingston Shoutouts newsletter sponsorship and see how a Kingston, NY business can turn a local ad placement into a clear invitation.

Nov 19, 2026
Darmstadt Overhead Doors: A Kingston Garage Door Shop on Cornell Street
Meet Darmstadt Overhead Doors on Cornell Street in Kingston, NY, and learn what to ask when comparing garage door repair and installation quotes.

Nov 19, 2026
All Star Roofing in Kingston: When a Ceiling Stain Gets Your Attention
A look at the Kingston-based roofing company and what homeowners can ask before agreeing to roof work.



11 Comments
Join the conversation
The garlic knots are my pick there. If you're grabbing food before a high school event, give yourself a little extra time since Broadway can get busy.
kim_87Good tip. I got stuck in that Broadway traffic before a school concert once. The knots were worth the wait, though.
I pass 440 on Broadway all the time but haven't tried the eggplant rollatini. Anyone know if it's as good as the pizza?
Rob EllisI've had the rollatini once and liked it. It's a pretty filling dinner, so I'd go hungry.
The eggplant rollatini is on the menu, but we haven’t tried it, so we can’t compare it with the pizza. If you give it a go, let us know what you think!
Letting those cyclists warm up and use the restroom on a cold, rainy day says a lot about the place. That kind of kindness sticks with people.
Jenna R.Especially on a rainy ride. Having somewhere to get warm can turn the whole day around.
I've had good slices at 440, but my last takeout order was a little uneven. I hope they keep working on consistency, because the prices make it worth coming back.
Dave ThompsonI've had an uneven takeout order too, but the next one was back to what I expected. The price keeps me giving them another shot.
The Family Deal has been a reliable dinner for us when nobody feels like cooking. The wings usually disappear before the second pizza gets opened.
Maria G.Same at our house. We started putting the wings on the table last so everyone actually eats some pizza.